Showing posts with label CM Punk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CM Punk. Show all posts

Monday, 12 December 2016

Night Of Champions 2012

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 167 Minutes
Certificate: 12
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: January 21 2013

The very first WWE DVD to be published by Fremantle Home Entertainment in the United Kingdom, the change-over from Clear/Silver Vision explains the delay in the release of this event, which was staged in September 2012. Was it worth the wait to see it on DVD? Kinda.

After John Bradshaw Layfield returns to provide commentary (replacing Jerry Lawler, who had suffered a heart attack just six days earlier during a live Raw show), NOC 2012 begins with a four-way for the Intercontinental Title between The Miz, Cody Rhodes, Rey Mysterio and Sin Cara which is good, but still feels like a disappointment, perhaps because arguably all four should be higher up the card than they presently are (or were at the time of this card). Next, the dysfunctional team of Kane and Daniel Bryan battle Kofi Kingston and R-Truth for the Tag Team Titles; it's the interaction and the mid-match hug between Kane and Bryan which carry this one, although the best part (of the show, actually) is Kane later screaming that "I'm going to Disneyland!" It's funnier to watch this happen than for me to describe it, obviously.

Antonio Cesaro vs. Zack Ryder is okay; Randy Orton vs. Dolph Ziggler, meanwhile, is a strong battle, if not quite their best to date. Layla vs. Eve is more story than match, as it relates to a pre-match assault on Kaitlyn by a mystery assailant, forcing Eve to replace her (hmm, who could have attacked her?). Sheamus vs. Alberto Del Rio is decent and thankfully ends their feud, and CM Punk vs. John Cena, from a pure technical standpoint, may be their best match to date, despite the somewhat frustrating finish (and why is Paul Heyman at ringside if he doesn't get involved whatsoever?).

In something of an uneven year on Pay-Per-View for WWE, if I'm being honest, Night Of Champions 2012 is not going to win any Best Card awards despite it boasting two really good matches and either title changes or storyline climaxes in other bouts. But there's all-around entertainment to just about warrant a purchase. If that doesn't do the trick, knowing that this show - as the first non-Silver Vision WWE DVD ever commercially released in the UK - is something of a collector's item to own on DVD probably will.

Overall Rating: 7/10 - Respectable

Hell In A Cell 2012

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 166 Minutes
Certificate: 15
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: January 28 2013

Unlike previous years, where WWE would overload the Hell In A Cell card with too many HIAC matches (there were three in 2009, none of which were particularly necessary), the 2012 event kept things simple with just the one Cell bout, a well-built collision between longtime WWE Champion CM Punk and the undefeated, Goldberg-like Ryback. That being said, it is another match which stands as the main reason to see this DVD.

Starting chronologically: Randy Orton vs. Alberto Del Rio is a good opener, if not the best match that the two could put together, followed by an entertaining yet forgettable bout pitting Team Hell No (arguably WWE's hottest act at the time of this PPV) against Team Rhodes Scholars. Kofi Kingston vs. The Miz is good, though, and a reminder that both men can deliver a thrilling contest despite each man's reduced status in recent times. Conversely, while well-executed, Antonio Cesaro bvs. Justin Gabriel isn't a PPV-calibre match, nor is Rey Mysterio & Sin Cara vs. The Prime Time Players

Fortunately, we get quite the unexpected treat in Sheamus vs. Big Show, which ends up being the best or second-best World Heavyweight Championship contest of 2012. The finish is a shocker, but in a good way, and Sheamus enhances his reputation by being able to get such a great match out of Show at this point in the giant's career; however, Show deserves credit for his performance, which rounds off what has been his best year in a long time. Eve Torres vs. Kaitlyn vs. Layla is a flat follow-up to Sheamus vs. Show, and despite the exciting build-up and intrigue as to who would win, WWE was in a no-win position to book CM Punk against Ryback in a Cell match (Ryback replaced the injured John Cena), as a defeat for neither man sounded particularly useful. As it is, WWE delves into its back of tricks to try and enhance both men's characters regardless of the result, but suffice it to say, Ryback's momentum hasn't quite been the same since he was fast-tracked into losing a PPV main event, just three months after beating Curt Hawkins and Tyler Reks in a PPV filler attraction. Match quality is okay, but it's nowhere near as memorable as The Undertaker vs. Triple H in the same structure nearly seven months earlier at WrestleMania XXVIII.

Mind you, Hell In A Cell 2012 is still an adequate show. Would I recommend buying it on DVD? Erm, not really: Sheamus vs. Big Show is well worth watching, and there are some good bouts elsewhere on the card, but I would only suggest that you buy this DVD if you see it at a discount price. A fun event, but not a must-own.

Overall Rating: 7/10 - Respectable

Survivor Series 2012

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 163 Minutes
Certificate: 12
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: March 11 2013

Compared to last year's Survivor Series, held in Madison Square Garden and hosting the in-ring return of The Rock as well as the beginning of CM Punk's historically-long WWE Title reign, Survivor Series 2012 is a more low-key event, with some of its content indistinguishable from typical action on Raw or SmackDown. Mind you, it features some good bouts and a major development at its climax, so it is also far from a dud either.

The opening 10-man Survivors match, whilst unannounced and feeling like filler, is enjoyable and contains some nice spots, all of which make it a fine way to start proceedings (although it demonstrates how far Rey Mysterio's star has fallen since his return from a long lay-off in July). Eve Torres vs. Kaitlyn is superior to typical Divas Title matches in recent times, whilst Antonio Cesaro vs. R-Truth really does exist solely to fill PPV time.

Big Show vs. Sheamus isn't as good as their corker at Hell In A Cell, but it is still a strong effort by both men, and despite the frustrating finish for a card of this significance (it's the third year in a row that the World Heavyweight Championship match at Survivor Series doesn't have a proper ending), the post-match scenes at least keep the crowd engaged and distract them from the fact that this was only a bridge to extend the feud between Show and Sheamus. The following Survivors match pitting Team Foley (although Mick is only a manager) against Team Ziggler is rather entertaining, but since this was originally meant to see CM Punk captain the heel squad, one wonders why the match really has reason to happen. It does see Dolph Ziggler achieve a major moment in his career, though.

The main event between CM Punk, John Cena and Ryback for the WWE Title is no better or worse than any three-way that you're likely to see, despite it being arguably the strongest match that WWE can present involving its full-time stars at present. What makes this match stand out is the arrival of Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose (since named The Shield), who make a huge impact in their WWE main roster debuts. If their fortunes since then have told us anything, it's that the trio represent the future of the company, and so this could one day be looked at with the same fondness as Survivors debuts for the likes of Rocky Maivia, Kurt Angle and The Undertaker.

That being said, their run-in is not enough to justify the purchase of this DVD, since on the whole it's an insignificant chapter in the history of Survivor Series. There's some good action for sure, but on the whole, the show (which, by the way, makes an error with its match listing on the back cover; see if you can spot it if you pick up a copy) is one that only die-hard fans and collectors will be interested in reliving. An entertaining show, but by no means WWE's best of the year.

Overall Rating: 6.5/10 - Okay

Friday, 9 December 2016

Royal Rumble 2013

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 169 Minutes
Certificate: 12
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: April 15 2013

Kicking off the year in WWE on PPV, Royal Rumble delivered a memorable main event with an outcome that seemed inconceivable just a short time ago, and some decent action elsewhere which makes for a fun DVD to watch.

The opening Last Man Standing match between Alberto Del Rio and Big Show is perhaps slightly inferior to their previous LMS meeting on SmackDown a few weeks earlier, but it's still entertaining nonetheless. Team Hell No vs. Team Rhodes Scholars is okay, and we then jump ahead to the Royal Rumble match itself. It's not the best Rumble by any means, but it does deliver some nice surprises and is overall superior to the 2012 effort.

Whether you appreciate CM Punk vs. The Rock depends on you as a fan, really. Some will understand that the match itself and its outcome were sensible, business-wise. Others will cry foul that Punk's historic 434-day reign gets - well - Rocked, so to speak, due to his part-time status. Assuming that you just take it for what it is, Punk vs. Rock is enjoyable and has a pretty dramatic finale, and is a historic and star-studded attraction after all. Also included is the pre-show match, pitting Antonio Cesaro against The Miz.

To be fair, most fans will get the DVD of Royal Rumble anywa, due to its legacy and its rich history. That being said, the 2013 edition should definitely entertain you, and similar to the match of the same name, it is an improvement on what we saw in 2012.

Overall Rating: 7.5/10 - Good

Elimination Chamber 2013

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 181 Minutes
Certificate: 12
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: May 6 2013

Elimination Chamber, traditionally the last PPV before WrestleMania, often has its memories lost once Mania is over and done with (more so than Royal Rumble, despite it coming after RR). And that's a shame because, as this DVD proves, the 2013 edition of Elimination Chamber had plenty to praise.

There are five matches that are good, really good or better. They are Alberto Del Rio vs. Big Show (despite an unintentional slip by ADR during the bout); the Elimination Chamber match with a World Heavyweight Title shot for WM 29 at stake; a six-man pitting The Shield against John Cena, Ryback and Sheamus; an impromptu showdown between Dolph Ziggler and Kofi Kingston; and a Royal Rumble rematch for the WWE Title between The Rock and CM Punk (how weird is it at this point to see Rock wrestle on what is essentially a B-show?).

Elsewhere, Antonio Cesaro vs. The Miz is inferior to their previous meeting prior to Royal Rumble, partly because of the finish; and Kaitlyn vs. Tamina Snuka is not as good as Kaitlyn's Divas Title-winning effort against Eve Torres at the 20th Anniversary episode of Raw. The bonus match between Tons Of Funk and Team Rhodes Scholars is also not up to much. However, the superior action that makes up the majority of the programme justify a purchase.

Elimination Chamber isn't always needed in one's collection to track the Road To WrestleMania; however, not only is EC a pivotal show en route to this year's Mania, but it's a wrestling DVD which is well worth owning in its own right.

Overall Rating: 8/10 - Very Good

Payback 2013

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 173 Minutes
Certificate: 12
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: August 26 2013

Despite a familiar line-up and the feelings of relative staleness due to the end of WrestleMania Season, Payback 2013 is surprisingly a great show to watch, and therefore the DVD should provide you with plenty of entertainment.

Here's why: after a very well-received opener for the Intercontinental Title, pitting Bad News Barrett against The Miz and Curtis Axel (replacing Fandango), we get the best Divas Title match since the days of Trish Stratus and Lita as AJ Lee and Kaitlyn put on one hell of a battle. Dean Ambrose vs. Kane admittedly has that filler feeling to it, but the same cannot be said about Dolph Ziggler vs. Alberto Del Rio, which is a World Title with a difference, namely the incredibly stiff offence (based around Ziggler's real-life concussion issues) and a double turn, which is well-executed.

CM Punk returns from a two-month absence to put on a thriller with Chris Jericho, and while the set-up of Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton vs. The Shield feels strange, it is nevertheless a lot of fun to see. The Three Stages Of Hell bout between John Cena and Ryback is a decent main event, even if it is actually one of the weaker matches on the card, albeit due to the high standard of several matches which came before it. The pre-show match between Sheamus and Damien Sandow is also worth watching.

So, don't let anyone tell you that WWE is only interesting on PPV in the run-up to WrestleMania, because Payback 2013 proves evidence to the contrary, and therefore becomes a DVD that is pretty highly recommended.

Overall Rating: 8/10 - Very Good

Battleground 2013

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 197 Minutes
Certificate: 15
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: January 6 2014

The first Battleground event has a decent line-up, but strangely misfires in several ways, making it feel like a glorified episode of Raw. Therefore, whilst not terrible, the DVD is a bit of a struggle to watch.

The opening Hardcore match between Alberto Del Rio and Rob Van Dam is pretty good, to be fair, and the big tag team showdown between The Shield and the combo of Cody Rhodes and Goldust is very dramatic.

However, there is too much filler. Besides an admittedly impressive spot at the finish, The Great Khali and Santino Marella vs. The Real Americans isn't PPV-worthy, nor is Curtis Axel vs. R-Truth. CM Punk vs. Ryback is mediocre and has a counterproductive finish. AJ Lee vs. Brie Bella is a step down from the matches between AJ and Kaitlyn. Kofi Kingston vs. Bray Wyatt has one highlight, that being Wyatt's spider-walk. And whilst Daniel Bryan vs. Randy Orton is a very good match, the finish is abrupt, a bit senseless and ends the show, and the DVD on a low note.

Mind you, the DVD has more bonus features than usual. Dolph Ziggler vs. Damien Sandow is thepre-Battleground bout, and as well as some additional interviews and angles, we're also treated to the Raw main event from the next night as Bryan, Cody and Goldust face all three members of The Shield.

Battleground has some really good matches, but they will likely up on future compilations, meaning you are best saving your money for those DVDs instead. One for die-hard collectors only.

Overall Rating: 5.5/10 - Above Average

Friday, 23 September 2016

WWE Best Pay-Per-View Matches 2013

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 435 Minutes
Certificate: 15
Number Of Discs: 3
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: January 13 2014

Once more, WWE has released a compilation focusing on the year's best Pay-Per-View encounters (well, those of the first ten months, anyway; and the match choices are always those of WWE, meaning some fan favourite bouts don't get a look-in). Renee Young takes over hosting duties here, with PPV posters to assist her, erm, links, and the artwork has a slightly grandiose theme highlighting WWE's biggest names ... except for Brock Lesnar. That Lesnar isn't included is unusual, and perhaps emphasises how his star doesn't shine quite as bright as it should presently. We don't get any promo videos for matches this time, which is a slight dampener.

Onto the action, though, and we have CM Punk vs. The Rock from Royal Rumble. Whilst a fun match to watch, that part-timer Rock was chosen to end Punk's 434-day WWE Title reign PO'd the hardcore fans to a great extent, especially with John Cena winning the Royal Rumble to set up Rock-Cena 2 as the main event for WrestleMania 29 (I personally didn't have a problem with the decision, although the fact that the People's Elbow was the move to finish Punk off ruined one's suspension of disbelief). After that, Elimination Chamber (an underrated show, in my opinion) gives us John Cena, Ryback and Sheamus vs. The Shield, a watchable yet fairly pointless match with a surprising outcome (at the time, anyway).

WrestleMania 29 is up next, and we're treated to two of Mania's top battles. The Undertaker vs. CM Punk is an awesome match, probably the best WWE match of the entire year; it isn't quite as good as Taker's WM showdowns with Shawn Michaels, but it is a classic nonetheless. Rock-Cena 2 has been criticised for simply existing by fans, meaning that they would have you think this match sucks. However, it's entertaining and tells a logical story of Cena learning (or thinking he had learned) from his mistake the previous Mania against Rock. Overall, it's probably a better match than their original in Miami, despite the fairly subdued atmosphere and the over-reliance on finishing moves near the end. I can understand fans moaning about this rematch because their WM 28 meeting was supposed to be "Once In A Lifetime", but did anyone truly believe that, especially when Cena lost in Miami? Besides, if WWE has a match that sets records and has massive appeal, why wouldn't they stage a rematch? Granted, the build-up to their second meeting was lazy by WWE, but that's beside the point.

Disc two brings us to Extreme Rules with two matches: a better-than-expected Extreme Rules battle between hometown hero Randy Orton and Big Show, and an exciting Steel Cage bout between Brock Lesnar and Triple H. Their feud went on for far too long despite this only being their third match, but it's engaging nonetheless. The only downside is that the crowd was so flat for their second clash at Mania, which was very well-executed; had the audience at MetLife Stadium (which I was a part of) responded better, the WM showdown could have been fondly remembered, and probably would have been included here too.

The focus on big names is reduced for the next few matches, as we get a couple of Payback bouts and a Money In The Bank Ladder match featuring much of WWE's upper mid-card crew. Wade Barrett vs. The Miz vs. Curtis Axel (replacing the injured Fandango) is decent and has a cool finish, but probably doesn't need to be here. AJ Lee vs. Kaitlyn, however, was the best WWE women's match in many years, and Dolph Ziggler vs. Alberto Del Rio is unexpectedly brutal and sees a double-turn pulled off brilliantly. As for the MITB Ladder match: it's a platform for Dean Ambrose, The Rhodes Scholars, The Real Americans, Fandango and Barrett to shine, and it is a really good stunt show, although it's still weird that WWE would hold a match starring seven heels and no babyfaces (even if one competitor, Cody Rhodes, begins his face turn during this encounter).

Disc three takes us to SummerSlam, probably the best PPV event of the year, and we get two big reasons why: CM Punk vs. Brock Lesnar is a believable and gripping war, and John Cena vs. Daniel Bryan is a thrilling, if slightly overrated, main event that has some huge post-match shenanigans which gave birth to what would become The Authority. Night Of Champions, in contrast, felt like a real B-PPV, as evidenced by the two bouts featured here: ADR vs. Rob Van Dam is good but not great and has a crap ending, and AJ vs. Natalya vs. Brie Bella vs. Naomi is average at best. Better is Cody and Goldust vs. Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns from Battleground, with the careers of both Rhodes brothers and the job as NXT chief of Dusty Rhodes at stake; there's a nice old-school feel to the match, mixed with the modern fast-paced, all-action style of those involved (and Goldust once again turns back the years with his performance here).

Hell In A Cell once again rounds off proceedings, as we get ADR vs. John Cena for the World Heavyweight Title (in Cena's comeback from a triceps injury, which was meant to sideline him until 2014 but instead saw him return after just 2 ½ months), which is watchable but nothing special, and Randy Orton vs. Daniel Bryan inside HIAC for the WWE Title (which Triple H had put into "abeyance", a fancy word for vacating it), and with Shawn Michaels as referee. It sounds like a classic waiting to happen but, whilst it is a good main event, there is something missing to prevent it being world-class, as was the case for all Orton vs. Bryan matches in the autumn of 2013, for some reason. Unlike previous entries in this series, one does not miss Survivor Series or TLC being absent because neither cards were exactly classics; that being said, Orton vs. Cena at TLC unified the World Titles, so that would have been a fitting way to round off the spotlight on 2013 supershows.

As it is, this is another good look back at WWE on PPV. I would have liked to see Lesnar-HHH from WrestleMania, Punk vs. Chris Jericho (CM's return from an extended absence) at Payback and ADR vs. Christian (an excellent little match) from SummerSlam, but the truly essential supershow matches are all here. Punk's two matches with Undertaker and Lesnar are the in-ring highlights, although Cena's matches with Rock and Bryan are the two most important from a storyline standpoint. Elsewhere, there's some good action across the board, with only a few matches feeling out of place. So, 2013 wasn't really the best year ever for WWE on Pay-Per-View, but most of the supershow highlights from that period can be found here.

Overall Rating: 8/10 - Very Good

WWE Best Pay-Per-View Matches 2012

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 385 Minutes
Certificate: 12
Number Of Discs: 3
Studio: Fremantle Home Entertainment
Released: March 4 2013

The Best Pay-Per-View Matches series would continue on to cover 2012, one of the most memorable years in recent times for WWE. Two huge WrestleMania matches, the return shortly afterwards of a major star, the year-long WWE Title run of the Best In The World, the entertainment provided by Team Hell No and the arrival of The Shield were just some of the reasons why there's a lot to remember about 2012. Much of it happened on Pay-Per-View, and a lot of that is covered here. Scott Stanford is again on hosting duties, and the artwork is a nice nod to the old-school wrestling posters from the 1970s and before. What's more, some promo videos are again included to explain why certain matches are happening, which is always a good thing.

We begin as ever at Royal Rumble, with CM Punk vs. Dolph Ziggler. It's a good match, but it's overshadowed by Punk's feud with special referee/enforcer John Laurinaitis, in Big Johnny's only appearance on the DVD, incidentally. The upshot is, Ziggler looks a bit weak as Punk has him beaten several times before finally finishing him off. Next up, the World Heavyweight Title Elimination Chamber had the potential to royally suck, but it ends up greatly exceeding expectations, and momentarily makes one believe that Santino Marella could indeed become the World Heavyweight Champion. Disc one closes with the outstanding Hell In A Cell war between The Undertaker and Triple H from WrestleMania XXVIII, refereed by Shawn Michaels and containing enough drama and action to justify why most people considered this to be the best match of the entire year.

Disc two simply had to open with The Rock vs. John Cena; their Once In A Lifetime (ahem) clash from WM XXVIII had been hyped up for a full year, and whilst it isn't as bad as some people suggest, nor is it as good as those who call it a classic would have you believe, it does live up to the hype, and it comes off as WWE intended; that being, the biggest WWE match in years (there arguably hasn't been a bigger showdown since). Extreme Rules is omitted completely, which is irksome since that was one of the year's top shows (perhaps Brock Lesnar's mauling of John Cena in his comeback match would have prevented this set achieving a PG rating), so we move to Over The Limit for an unmemorable Divas Title clash between Layla and Beth Phoenix, and an enjoyable Christian-Cody Rhodes bout from No Way Out. Disc two ends with a strong CM Punk-Daniel Bryan No Holds Barred battle from Money In The Bank, although I would have preferred to see their superior, outstanding wrestling collision from Over The Limit than this one, which is very good but relies too much on where special referee AJ Lee's intentions lie.

Disc three kicks off with Brock Lesnar vs. Triple H from SummerSlam, which is far better than I remembered it being at the time (the crowd goes a bit quiet at some points, which is why some felt it came off badly when it was held, but it's nothing like the silence we've seen greet some more recent matches). Night Of Champions gives us two very good matches in Randy Orton vs. Dolph Ziggler (this is the Viper's only appearance on the DVD in what was a fairly forgettable year for him) and CM Punk vs. John Cena (the double-pin finish fooled a lot of fans into believing that Cena had indeed regained the WWE Championship). The set ends with Sheamus vs. Big Show for the World Title from Hell In A Cell, which would surpass expectations by a wide margin and end up being one of the best matches in Show's entire career. For those who say that Sheamus is dull and can't wrestle today, they should take another look at his efforts here.

Once again, Survivor Series and TLC are omitted and, once again, it is to the detriment of this collection. While Survivor Series wasn't a vintage show by any means, it did include the first appearance by The Shield, and their official debut match at TLC, under TLC rules opposite Ryback and Team Hell No, was outstanding and would have been a more-than-worthy inclusion here. As it is, though, the compilation wraps up at Hell In A Cell. Have I mentioned yet that this is a frustrating trend with the Best PPV Matches DVDs?

Based on what we do have here, though, this is another fine entry in the series. Taker vs. HHH is a classic, and there are at least another half-a-dozen matches that are really good or in some way memorable. That two of the year's best encounters (Punk vs. Bryan from Over The Limit and The Shield's debut at TLC) are not included knocks this down a peg, but one should thoroughly enjoy this look back at 2012 on PPV nonetheless.

Overall Rating: 8/10 - Very Good

Thursday, 22 September 2016

WWE Best Pay-Per-View Matches 2011

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 422 Minutes
Certificate: 15
Number Of Discs: 3
Studio: Clear Vision Ltd/Silver Vision
Released: March 26 2012

The Best Pay-Per-View Matches series returned to DVD to cover the big encounters of 2011. This time, the structure was more logical by focusing on the year as a whole rather than a "season". The downside is that WWE chose to release this collection at the tail end of 2011 in the U.S. (meaning, the very beginning of 2012 in the UK), all of which meant that Survivor Series and TLC, the final two supershows of the year, were held too late to be covered in this DVD. This is a trend that has continued ever since, and hopefully one which WWE will end at some point; if you're recapping the year's best matches, you can't justifiably ignore two major shows that close the annum out.

That aside, the 2011 set is a very good round-up of top-drawer matches. Disc one opens with two great Edge matches: a singles battle with Dolph Ziggler from Royal Rumble, and an Elimination Chamber scrap (at the event of the same name) against Rey Mysterio, Kane, Wade Barrett, Drew McIntyre and Big Show. The Chamber bout in particular is excellent, and an example of how this match can still provide thrills and spills in a PG environment.

We head to WrestleMania XXVII for the next two matches: by most accounts, the 27th Mania was disappointing, but Rey vs. Cody Rhodes (featured here) is alright, and The Undertaker vs. Triple H (which closes out the first disc) is an incredibly dramatic battle; yes, it's slow-paced and it's more a collection of spots rather than a back-and-forth match, but it works, and it puts the Streak in the most jeopardy that it would ever be, prior to Brock Lesnar actually ending it three years later.

Disc two kicks off with a Ladder match from Extreme Rules between Christian and Alberto Del Rio for the vacated World Heavyweight Title, which is pretty good if not the most exciting Ladder bout that you'll ever see. Over The Limit is ignored altogether, which is annoying because Randy Orton vs. Christian from that show was one of the year's genuine best WWE matches. Capitol Punishment makes up for this slightly with a really good Rey Mysterio-CM Punk match, at which point the seeds were being sown for a certain wrestler to suddenly become the centre of attention (hint: he's Straight-Edge).

From there, it's off to Money In The Bank, which gives us a strong Raw MITB Ladder match involving Del Rio, Rey, R-Truth, The Miz, Jack Swagger, Kofi Kingston, Evan Bourne and Alex Riley (remember him?). I personally would have preferred seeing the SmackDown MITB clash here instead, but it's still really good. And then we head to that card's main event to close disc two: John Cena (in his first appearance of the DVD, surprisingly) vs. CM Punk for the WWE Title, in front of a red-hot Chicago crowd. It isn't quite flawless, but it is an extremely compelling main event backed up by one hell of a storyline (the match is preceded by the promo video detailing the Punk-is-leaving storyline, the only time such a device is used in this particular set). This is one of the two most memorable matches of the year, alongside Taker-HHH, and the match and the wider storyline is a reason why many fans decided to start watching WWE again. If that isn't an endorsement, I don't know what is.

Disc three starts strong with Randy Orton vs. Christian (at last, one of their matches!) under No Holds Barred rules from SummerSlam, which aside from a subsequent Cage match on SmackDown brought an end to what was the year's best rivalry bar none. After that, the match quality begins to dip as we see Mark Henry challenge Orton for the World Heavyweight Title at Night Of Champions; it plays to Henry's strengths (no pun intended), but it's the weakest match of the DVD up to that point. HHH vs. Punk from NOC is here too, and is a very good, wild brawl, although it gets a bit overcrowded with interference and shenanigans, and the result (a HHH win, with no real follow-up) is one of the reasons why Punk would leave WWE for real in 2014.

The standard takes a nose-dive when we get to Hell In A Cell. A generally mediocre event, it gives us two matches, neither of which are particularly worth watching: Kelly Kelly vs. Beth Phoenix, in the days when the word "Diva" was of greater importance to WWE than actual female wrestling talent, is lifeless and loses the crowd when Kelly practically cries due to the pain of a submission hold (what the hell?). Cena vs. Punk vs. ADR is okay, but it's a match held inside a Hell In A Cell rather than a Hell In A Cell match, if that makes sense; although the finish makes use of the structure, this really didn't need to be inside that massive cage. (The post-match scenes involving Awesome Truth are fairly memorable, though.) Lastly, it's Henry vs. Big Show from Vengeance; in fairness to the slow, cumbersome giants, the match is better than expected, and the finish (which I won't spoil here, even if the DVD cover for that actual event did indeed spoil what happened), whilst recycled, allows the DVD to end on a high note of sorts.

Other notes: Scott Stanford provides hosting duties, and the box art looks like it has had some effort put into it this year. Again, I wish WWE would have delayed the release to cover Survivor Series and TLC; TLC had plenty of memorable moments, whilst Survivors saw Punk begin his 434-day WWE Title reign at Alberto's expense, and the teaming of The Rock and John Cena against Miz and R-Truth. Partly because of that decision, one would never know from watching this DVD that Rock vs. Cena was a huge part of the WWE landscape in 2011 as they expertly built very slowly to their WrestleMania XXVIII clash the following year (although Stanford does give a slight reference to that match as the DVD ends).

With the exception of there being no Orton-Christian match from Over The Limit here and the lack of action from the year's final two PPV events, the title of this collection is pretty accurate, as all of the year's most exciting, memorable or important supershow battles are here. Some choose to remember 2011 for Cena vs. Punk at Money In The Bank; for others, it's Undertaker vs. HHH; and a few might remember the less credited matches such as the World Heavyweight Championship clash from Elimination Chamber. Whatever the case may be, this is a thoroughly enjoyable collection of action, which maintains a strong standard across the first two discs and has some surprises, twists and turns during some of the less fondly-remembered matches. If you want to relive WWE in 2011, this is a very good set to watch.

Overall Rating: 8.5/10 - Excellent

Thursday, 18 August 2016

John Morrison: Rock Star

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 168 Minutes
Certificate: 15
Number Of Discs: 1
Studio: Clear Vision Ltd/Silver Vision
Released: May 10 2010

With three-disc sets being the norm nowadays, even for compilations undeserving of the extended treatment, it was good to see a change in the formula for this single-disc release on John Morrison, at a time when he was one of WWE's top rising stars. This DVD brings together eight Morrison matches, along with comments from Morrison about his career and about his passions outside of the ring, such as parkour (which would later be used as part of his character) and surfing. The DVD tries to show Morrison's sense of humour in segments on The Dirt Sheet and answering fan questions, although the clips from the Dirt Sheet (which he sued to host on WWE.com with The Miz) are mostly embarrassingly unfunny, and the humorous answers only provide mild chuckles.

The real purpose of this is to demonstrate Morrison's wrestling ability. We aren't really enlightened into his career prior to becoming John Morrison (he co-won Tough Enough in 2003, trained in OVW after that for around a year, had a short-lived run as Eric Bischoff's assistant Johnny Nitro on Raw before returning to OVW, came back to the main roster alongside Joey Mercury and then-girlfriend Melina as part of the dynamic MNM act in 2005, had a decent solo run from 2006-7 and after becoming ECW Champion at Vengeance 2007, as a replacement for Chris Benoit on that fateful weekend, he shortly renamed himself John Morrison in a segment on ECW which is included as a DVD extra), so the first bout comes from Morrison's ECW Title reign; or, more accurately, the end of this run. His title-losing effort to CM Punk is a tremendous match, though, and probably the best ever match on WWE's ECW show. Given that he originally became champion due to Benoit's absence, which led to a raid of Benoit's doctor Phil Astin's surgery and the enquiry into what would become the Signature Pharmacy scandal, it is slightly ironic that Morrison was amongst those caught up in the scandal, meaning that this title loss was necessitated by his resultant suspension (and Punk, the noted straight-edge wrestler, was the man who beat him).

On a lighter note, Morrison rebounded by overachieving with his team alongside Miz, which went so well that it prepared Miz for an unimaginably successful solo run. The match from their double tag title-winning run comes in a non-title clash with D-Generation X leaders Shawn Michaels and Triple H from the Raw episode that celebrated 800 episodes (note that this wasn't the 800th episode; it's too long to explain). Right after the 2009 Draft split up Morrison and Miz, Johnny boy had his final ECW bout with Evan "Air" Bourne, which is the next clash featured here, and is an underrated gem of a match, and a sign that Bourne should be amongst the names that WWE could have looked to rehire ahead of this year's Brand Extension (come to think of it, WWE should rehire Morrison too, if they are legally able to do so given his Lucha Underground status).

After that, the focus for the remainder of the DVD switches to Morrison's SmackDown tenure. From May 2009 onwards for a good few months, SmackDown was a fantastic wrestling show; each week, it had one or two great wrestling matches, generally consisting of two or more from Rey Mysterio, Jeff Hardy, Edge, Chris Jericho, CM Punk and Morrison himself. The final five matches of this eight-bout DVD see the former Johnny Nitro take on each of the aforementioned names, with mixed results when it comes to wins and losses, but with each one of them being a strong wrestling encounter.

Morrison vs. Chris Jericho from Superstars is very good, and note how Y2J makes sure to remain the heel and cheats to win, which is picked up by announcers Jim Ross and Todd Grisham (the latter is an area where WWE does not succeed today). The episode of SmackDown which aired the next night featured the following match on the DVD, Morrison vs. Edge, which is superb; if not for another encounter later in the DVD, it would have been the best WWE television match of 2009. Edge makes Morrison look great, and even though the veteran comes out on top, the match greatly enhanced the younger Morrison.

Next up, Morrison scores an unlikely win over then-World Heavyweight Champion CM Punk (who was in the middle of a slow-burn heel turn) in a match which is exciting, but is inferior to Morrison vs. Edge. Morrison vs. Jeff Hardy five weeks later for the title is excellent; it's hard to envision a better situation when you have a rising star losing his big World Title opportunity, because it didn't harm Morrison one bit. (Although it has no relevance to Morrison, it's a minor disappointment that the post-match capers, where Punk completed his heel turn on Jeff, aren't included here.) The DVD ends with a bang; a genuine classic between Morrison and Rey Mysterio for the Intercontinental Title. Morrison's biggest triumph in WWE is a flawless battle, the best of many great SmackDown bouts in 2009, and had this not been the year when The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels ascended to new heights at WrestleMania 25, this would have been the undisputed Match Of The Year. (As an aside, this result was instigated by Mysterio violating the Wellness Policy, making it the third title change scenario involving Morrison that was caused by a suspension or an absence of some kind.)

Watching this, I tried to work out why SmackDown in 2009 felt better than Raw does today, even though both boasted or currently boast great matches every week (and Raw had the full roster prior to the latest Draft). Besides the superior creative for SmackDown seven years ago, and two top bouts in two hours being better than one or two great matches over the course of three hours, the main thing I noticed here was the selling. Matches start fast-paced but slow down as the competitors have taken a visual beating, and the wear and tear is evident in the final few minutes of each match. Wrestlers looked strong, even in defeat, and results had an impact on future developments. Selling is the key, whereas today Dean Ambrose or Seth Rollins will have a great 20-25 minute match but won't look any worse for the wear at the end, meaning that the matches have less of an impact. If wrestlers today did a better job of selling, the product would seem a lot better. And matches today have that 50/50 feel to them, rather than being a case of who is the best on the night wins, and goes on to achieve bigger things.

Returning to the DVD subject: this is a fantastic look at part of Morrison's career, especially the 2009 bouts. There isn't one weak match on the DVD, and besides the good-but-not-great tag bout, they are all either very good, excellent or, in the case of Morrison-Mysterio, classic. It's hard to believe from watching this that Morrison ultimately did not end up capturing either the WWE or World Heavyweight Titles. Certainly, a 2010 push for the gold seemed assured, and Morrison becoming champion of the SmackDown brand would have been greatly welcomed by fans. Somehow, it didn't happen, and so Morrison's fans are left hoping for a day when he might return to WWE, having left in late 2011, and become World Champion then. Otherwise, fans of the current Johnny Mundo can still enjoy his work on Lucha Underground.

Nevertheless, considering that the single-disc nature of this DVD makes this seem less important than most DVDs released around the same time, and despite the disappointing absence of any pre-Morrison content, this is an excellent wrestling DVD that provides a nice look back at a great time for wrestling action on SmackDown, and a look at someone who seemed destined to achieve great things. Who knows whether he will in future?

Overall Rating: 8.5/10 - Excellent

Thursday, 28 May 2015

CM Punk: Best In The World

Image Source: Amazon
Written By: Mark Armstrong

Running Time: 427 Minutes
Certificate: 15
Number Of Discs: 3
Studio: Clear Vision Ltd/Silver Vision
Released: October 29 2012

Before the Yes Movement elevated Daniel Bryan, diehard WWE fans were firmly behind CM Punk. The Chicago native brought an unconventional yet exciting in-ring and promo style, and a straight-edge character (no smoking, drinking or drugs, modelled on his real-life code of ethics), up through the indies and onto the main stage, which captured the imagination of those looking for a new hero, particularly someone who didn't come across as a John Cena clone. But his road to the top was bumpy, and no matter what Punk did in the ring, it seemed his fate was sealed to be nothing more than an upper mid-carder. Then, he cut a famous promo which would become known as the "Pipe Bomb", and Punk used the momentum off this to catapult himself to the WWE Title.

This 2012 DVD is largely based on a documentary which charts CM Punk's life and times, from his challenging upbringing to his breakthrough in wrestling on the independent circuit. Of note during his early days, Punk shone in Ring Of Honor, particularly in a feud with Samoa Joe. We see clips of this rivalry and other scraps with the likes of Raven, and we also see Punk return to the ROH training centre, a surreal sight on a WWE DVD at the time. There is no mention of Punk's time in TNA, but everywhere and almost everything else is covered, up until his signing with WWE in 2005.

Nowadays, many up-and-comers - even talent well-known by hardcore fans - start their WWE careers on NXT. In 2005, the developmental centre was Ohio Valley Wrestling, but OVW was not where Punk wanted to be; Paul Heyman reveals that Punk "was p---ed beyond belief" that he had to go to developmental. That this is highlighted is surprising, but had we been told that apparently Punk had originally signed a proper WWE wrestler contract, and would then be told why Punk had a WWE match meant for Heat which wasn't broadcast and was then sent to OVW after harsh criticism from higher-ups, this chapter of the documentary would have been extremely compelling.

Still, Punk had an ally in then-OVW boss Heyman, and this led to Punk coming to the WWE-led ECW in summer 2006. He got over immediately as a straight edge babyface with striking combat skills, and was unbeaten for most of the year. The December To Dismember fiasco is touched upon, but more to show how Punk's ECW direction soon suffered. Still, he became ECW Champ in 2007, and broke through in WWE proper by winning Money In The Bank at WrestleMania XXIV and cashing in on Edge to become World Heavyweight Champion on June 30 2008.

Punk's first World Title run suffered from the way he was booked, particularly from him losing the crown after being deemed unable to compete following an attack by the future Legacy. Of greater note are his two 2009 runs as Champ, during which time Punk became a straight-edge preaching heel and became a proper main eventer. His title loss and slide down the card is alluded to, but the inside story is not entirely covered (apparently Punk rejected The Undertaker's suggestion to wear suits outside the ring because then-WWE Champ John Cena didn't; Punk soon lost the title to Taker himself, went off the main event radar, and eventually ended up losing a dark match before the first TLC PPV).

His revival as leader of the Straight Edge Society is covered in-depth (Punk admits the similarities between his 2010 role and Jesus were deliberate, and deliberately controversial), but another subsequent slump led to Punk eyeing up the WWE exit when his contract expired in 2011, especially since he admits to being offended that The Miz was pushed ahead of him as WWE Champ going into WrestleMania XXVII.

But then he began a feud with Cena for the title heading into Money In The Bank 2011, and he cut the aforementioned Pipe Bomb promo (shown here in full) which was ground-breakingly realistic for a wrestling show. The momentum from this and his reality-based character led him to the title at MITB despite his contract expiring. Clearly, though, he had resigned with the company and stayed with WWE, winning the title again at Survivor Series 2011 to begin a 434-day reign.

The documentary only covers up to Punk's post-MITB 2011 reappearance, although some 2012 clips are scattered throughout. The DVD precedes the end of his long title run (it was in progress at the time, so it isn't mentioned here), his memorable match with Taker at WM 29, and of course his notorious split from WWE after Royal Rumble 2014, which has now led him to sign with UFC (I was thinking how darkly comical it would be to re-release this with his November 2014 podcast explaining why he left WWE as a bonus feature).

The documentary is one of WWE's greatest to date: it comprehensively covers most of Punk's life and career; the main feature and extras include revelations and trivia notes (what the "CM" stands for, who originated the GTS etc); it has contributions from many relevant people; and, above anything, it is extremely honest, at times brutally so (Punk even admits to tearing up promo scripts during his 2009 headline run). The only downside is that one is left with the impression that Punk is not a very nice man outside the ring (Michael Hayes even calls him "a moody pr--k"), although some stories show that he does have a good side to him. His opinions are always very much his true feelings, but at times the bigger picture isn't acknowledged: for instance, Miz had been slowly pushed to the top for over a year before WM 27, so whilst Punk is unquestionably better than Miz, one can understand why he was in the main event of that show before Punk.

Nevertheless, the documentary is utterly gripping for any wrestling fan. CM Punk as a person (rather than as a wrestler; there is a difference between the two) is someone you either love or hate. The main feature highlights his talent and positive traits, but does not ignore his flaws. So, whether you like him or you don't, the documentary should give you a perfect reason to opt for one particular emotion towards him. It is one of the best wrestler documentaries ever.

The DVD includes bonus matches, many of a high quality. There unfortunately are no ROH matches, but an OVW bout is here. We see his ECW debut and his great ECW Title win over John Morrison. His breakthrough MITB win at WM 24 is a spectacular bout; his Tag Team and Intercontinental Title wins are nice inclusions; and his TLC match with Jeff Hardy at SummerSlam 2009 and Hair vs. SES membership clash with Rey Mysterio at Over The Limit 2010 are both very exciting for different reasons. His MITB 2011 showdown with John Cena is one of the most memorable matches of the last decade, and his lengthy WWE Title run is represented by a pretty good bout with Chris Jericho at WM 28 and a superb match with Daniel Bryan from Over The Limit 2012.

The selection of matches is very good, but they are overshadowed by the brutally honest documentary. The one negative of watching this DVD in 2015 is that Punk has since left under a black cloud, and if he ever does return to WWE, it won't be for many years. Still, the man himself undoubtedly left behind a great in-ring legacy, and anybody who wants to know who CM Punk was and what he meant to people should definitely buy this, as it gives one a complete look at CM Punk, the wrestler, and Phil Brooks, the man. For wrestling fans, CM Punk: Best In The World is an essential purchase.

Overall Rating: 9.5/10 - Classic